Ex Parte STEVENS - Page 6




           Appeal No. 2002-0727                                                                     
           Application No. 08/869,878                                                               
           execute a combination of stores and fetches independently and in                         
           parallel (column 7, lines 46-57) and provides fault tolerance in                         
           the event of chip failure (column 17, line 51 – column 18, line                          
           27).                                                                                     
                 We do not see any disclosure of assigning partitions to                            
           unique processors for storage operations, although there is a                            
           discussion at column 17 relating to read-only data storage.                              
                 Pierce teaches providing each of a plurality of processors                         
           with its own local cache (column 5, lines 35-47).  The processors                        
           share a common memory which has portions assigned to each of the                         
           processors (column 5, lines 53-57).  This is said to enhance data                        
           integrity and reduce the so-called snoop operation which checks to                       
           make sure processors do not maintain separate local caches of the                        
           same information which may have been separately manipulated.                             
           (column 5, lines 60-61).                                                                 
                 However, we fail to see (1) why one of ordinary skill in the                       
           art would replace the shared cache of Brenza with the separate                           
           caches of Pierce, and (2) even were one so motivated, how the                            
           combination of Brenza and Pierce would yield the claimed subject                         
           matter.                                                                                  
                 As to the first point, Pierce teaches using completely                             
           separate caches for each processor and assigned common memory                            
           portions to reduce the snooping operation, which is inconsistent                         

                                                 6                                                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007