Ex Parte Regnier et al - Page 21




             Appeal No. 2005-1216                                                                                    
             Application No. 10/117,453                                                                              
             nucleic acids, polysaccharides, phospholipids, and polypeptides.”  Fodor, col. 8, lines                 
             21-30.  As further discussed above, a reactant is something which is involved in a                      
             chemical reaction.  Thus, we find that the reagents used in the synthesis reactions                     
             described by Fodor; e.g., the nucleic acids used to synthesize an oligonucleotide, the                  
             amino acids used to synthesize a polypeptide, etc., are reactants. Thus, we find that                   
             Fodor also discloses each and every element of the sample holders recited in claims 31                  
             and 38-41 which are directed to support surfaces which comprise a sample, a polymer,                    
             biopolymer, reactant and nucleotide probe, respectively.                                                
                    Finally, we point out that Fodor discloses that “the exposed regions” of the                     
             sample holder or “the area upon which each distinct polymer sequence is synthesized .                   
             . . is less than about 10,000 µm2 [in preferred embodiments] or, more preferably less                   
             than 100 µm2.”  Fodor, col. 9, lines 10-15.  Accordingly, we find that Fodor anticipates                
             sample holders having a multiplicity of non-removable islands which comprise a sample                   
             support surface and which are separated by a sump that inhibits transport of samples                    
             between adjacent sample support surfaces, “wherein the sample support surfaces are                      
             less than about 10,000 µm2”,  and “less than about 1,000 µm2” as recited in claims 32                   
             and 33.                                                                                                 








                                                         21                                                          





Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007