Ex Parte Short - Page 20



          Interference No. 105,188                                                    
          Short v. Punnonnen                                                          
               level of random point mutations introduced at each cycle               
               would be much lower if existing, already proven, point                 
               mutations or combinations could be permuted by                         
               recombination.                                                         
   5                                                                                  
          (Exh. 2052, p. 550, col. 2, paragraph bridging cols. 1-2);                  
                    Since recombination can occur even with “naked” DNA,              
               “it would seem that it would be easy to employ recombination           
  10           techniques in order to evolve complex sequences-or even                
               whole genomes-at the benchtop.  But in reality this has not            
               been the case.  To the surprise of most researchers,                   
               recombination methods for mutagenesis, selection, and                  
               replication have been extremely difficult to develop in the            
  15           laboratory.                                                            
          (Exh. 2052, pp. 550-551, bridging para.);                                   
                    So far, a technique called sexual PCR, or DNA                     
  20           shuffling, comes closest to mimicking natural recombination            
               by allowing the in vitro homologous recombination of DNA.              
          (Exh. 2052, p. 551, col. 1, first full para.);                              
  25                This method offers practical and theoretical advantages           
               over existing recursive mutagenesis methods, such as error-            
               prone PCR or recursive oligonucleotide directed mutagenesis.           
               By recombining point mutations and wild-type sequences,                
                                                  [3]                                 
               followed by selection for function,  sexual PCR will                   
  30           rapidly fine tune the mutation load present in different               
               parts of a protein.  Over several cycles, those areas that             
               tolerate a high mutation load accumulate more diversity than           
               those areas that are less permissive to modification.                  
  35      (Exh. 2052, p. 551, cols. 1-2, bridging para.);                             
                    Sexual PCR’s advantages for searching sequence space              
               can be further explained by understanding how it employs               
               poolwise and pairwise recombination strategies.                        
  40           Recombination by sexual PCR is, in principal, poolwise-more            
               than two parental sequences can contribute to form the                 

               3                                                                      
                    This resembles the procedure used in the Freeman PCT              
          (Exh. 2040, pp. 22-23, bridging para.).                                     
                                        -20-                                          




Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007