Ex Parte Short - Page 26



          Interference No. 105,188                                                    
          Short v. Punnonnen                                                          
          recursive sequence recombinations, to produce novel DNA which               
          encodes a polypeptide having desirably enhanced properties.                 
               Accordingly, we conclude that the combined teachings of the            
          Freeman PCT, the Short PCT, and Stemmer reasonably would have led           
   5      persons having ordinary skill in the art to optimize the                    
          modulatory effect of B7-2 variants encoded by novel DNA produced            
          by homologous recombination by:  a) creating a library of                   
          recombinant DNA encoding B7-2, b) promoting sequence                        
          recombination in the recombinant DNA library, c) screening the              
  10      library for novel recombinant DNA which exhibits an enhanced                
          ability to modulate an immune response induced by a genetic                 
          vaccine vector, and optimizing the enhanced ability of the novel            
          recombinant DNA to modulate the immune response by recursive DNA            
          sequence recombination, and reasonably expect success.                      
  15           Subject matter defined by Punnonen’s Claim 47 appears to be            
          unpatentable under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as having been prima facie               
          obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art in view of             
          the combined teachings of the Freeman PCT, the Short PCT, and               
          Stemmer.  Therefore, we recommend that further examination and              
  20      subsequent action relating to the patentability of the subject              




                                        -26-                                          




Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007