Appeal No. 2006-0406 Application 09/497,865 which includes the claimed multiplexer, analog to digital converter, and circuitry for forming multiple digital beams and that a digital receiver would be inherent (FR3). The examiner finds that Aoki teaches digital processing which automatically transmits beams in the direction of the arriving beam (FR2). The examiner concludes that it would have been obvious to modify Karlsson to use a DBF to achieve the advantages taught by Chiba, to use the specific DBF technique of Chang, and to process a transmission signal in the direction of the received signal in view of the retrodirectivity teachings of Aoki (FR3). Karlsson discloses a phased array antenna mounted on top of an elevation table which is mounted to an azimuth turntable. The antenna can be scanned both by mechanically rotating the azimuth table and moving the elevation table and by electronic scanning of the antenna elements by changing their relative phase relationship (col. 6, lines 37-43). Normally the boresight of the antenna is pointed at the satellite with which it is in communication (col. 7, lines 2-6). During handoff from one satellite to another, the boresight of the antenna is physically scanned to a positioning vector intermediate the vectors defining the respective positions of the coming and going satellites (col. 7, lines 32-35) and then the antenna is electronically scanned to move the antenna beam from the going satellite to the coming satellite (col. 7,, lines 52-63) which results in - 6 -Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007