Ex Parte Koh et al - Page 5



               Appeal No. 2006-2407                                                                                                 
               Application No. 09/802,857                                                                                           



               artisan and to us that they would also be connected under a common bus                                               
               environment as in figure 3 even as the discussion at the beginning of column 6 of                                    
               Sagane as to the second embodiment in figure 3 relies in part upon the structural                                    
               elements in the first embodiment in figure 1.  These in turn are further modified                                    
               according to the additional teaching at the top of column 7 of the need or proposal                                  
               of an additional modification of the second embodiment to interpose a control flag                                   
               switch 7a and switch 7c of figure 1 between the comparator 8 and the switch 23 in                                    
               the figure 3 or second embodiment.  This appears to relate to the additional                                         
               modification of duplicated structures just mentioned to accommodate the sequential                                   
               switching between a plurality of bugs in the program.                                                                
                       Before we treat the teachings in Hosotani, independent claim 13 on appeal                                    
               does not require that the central processing unit receive the plurality of coincidence                               
               signals at the same time.  Thus, the claim is consistent with the teaching value of                                  
               Sagane of the ability as modified according to the just-noted teachings of the figure                                
               3 embodiment to accommodate  sequentially separate bugs.  Implicit with this                                         
               understanding then is the ability of the system to generate a plurality of different                                 


                                                                 5                                                                  




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007