Ex Parte Koh et al - Page 7



               Appeal No. 2006-2407                                                                                                 
               Application No. 09/802,857                                                                                           



               would effectively bypass its normal program sequencing to eliminate the program                                      
               bug within its normal programming in ROM 3 upon the normal operation of the                                          
               plurality comparators 8 in figure 3, the effect of the operation of the system in                                    
               figure 3 is to function in a manner analogous to an interrupt as directly taught in the                              
               embodiment in figure 1 of Sagane.  In this manner, the functional analogy of                                         
               Sagane is consistent with the broad recitation of dependent claims 19 and 20 that                                    
               Sagane would effectively receive the plurality of coincidence signals “as” a single                                  
               or plural/separate interrupts, since Sagane has the capability to perform both                                       
               according to the modified teachings of figure 3 to accommodate plural bugs.                                          
                       We agree as well with the examiner’s remarks at least at pages 4 through 6 of                                
               the answer that the mere reception of the coincidence signals by the CPU of claim                                    
               13 does not require explicitly a direct connection or a direct coupling.  We therefore                               
               agree with the examiner’s indirect coupling or indirect connectability arguments in                                  
               the answer.                                                                                                          






                                                                 7                                                                  




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007