Ex Parte Shin - Page 10



             Appeal 2007-0002                                                                                    
             Application 10/188,485                                                                              
             crowns C, heels H and patties P which have been removed from the storage                            
             sections 8C, 8H, and 8P and used in the completed sandwiches” (Naramura, col. 9,                    
             ll. 15-25).  As such, Naramura discloses concurrently initiating toasting of a crown                
             and heel and grilling of sandwich contents, i.e., a patty, using different cooking                  
             methods.                                                                                            
                   12. Naramura acknowledges that “[a] demand for heightened productivity                        
             has arisen as a result of an increase in the number of consumers and increasingly                   
             diversified tastes” (Naramura, col. 1, ll. 19-21).                                                  
                   13. Naramura discloses that its sandwich preparation apparatus can be                         
             used for production of “a wide variety of hamburgers and sandwiches” (Naramura,                     
             col. 4, ll. 9-11) and that one advantage of the sandwich preparation apparatus is to                
             heighten productivity by eliminating idling time from waiting for completion of                     
             toasting or grilling (Naramura, col. 4, ll. 19 and 36-38 and col. 9, ll. 26-30).                    
                   14. Naramura does not disclose grilling vegetables as part of the sandwich                    
             contents.                                                                                           
                   15. Naramura also does not explicitly state the relative amount of time it                    
             takes to toast the bun halves and grill the patty.                                                  
                   16. Naramura also does not disclose toasting the crowns and heels by                          
             impinging heated air.                                                                               
                   17. Russell teaches an electric appliance for cooking meat and buns                           
             simultaneously (Russell, Abstract).                                                                 
                   18. Russell recognizes that meat requires more heat to become cooked                          
             than does a bun to become warmed or toasted.  Russell teaches that “[i]n order to                   

                                                       10                                                        



Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013