Ex Parte Bull - Page 6

                Appeal 2007-0472                                                                               
                Application 09/931,817                                                                         
                describes a treasure hunt type game whereby clues are communicated to the                      
                players of the game through a website having advertisements.  In playing                       
                such a game, solving a clue necessarily involves interacting with the                          
                advertising website.                                                                           
                      Turning to the claim, it describes a game featuring “an advertising                      
                object and a clue involving the advertising object, wherein solving the clue                   
                includes interacting with the advertising object.”  When given its broadest                    
                reasonable construction consistent with the Specification (FF 11), the phrase                  
                “an advertising object” encompasses a website with advertisements.                             
                Therefore, in calling for “an advertising object and a clue involving the                      
                advertising object, wherein solving the clue includes interacting with the                     
                advertising object,” the claim encompasses a game featuring an advertising                     
                website and a clue involving the advertising website wherein solving the                       
                clue involves interacting with the advertising website.                                        
                      Because the claim encompasses a game featuring an advertising                            
                website and a clue involving the advertising website wherein solving the                       
                clue involves interacting with the advertising website, it reads on the Sporgis                
                method, i.e., a treasure hunt type game whereby clues are communicated to                      
                the players of the game through a website having advertisements wherein                        
                solving a clue necessarily involves interacting with the advertising website.                  
                      As to that part of the contention which argues that Sporgis fails to                     
                disclose or suggest a game that creates awareness of a sponsor, since we                       
                have found that Sporgis discloses and/or suggests the step in the claims that                  
                creates the awareness of a sponsor, i.e., the step of interacting with an                      
                advertising object, we furthermore find Sporgis discloses and/or suggests the                  
                result of that step, i.e., creating awareness of a sponsor.                                    

                                                      6                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013