Ex Parte Tilton - Page 6

                Appeal  2007-1168                                                                                
                Application 10/211,407                                                                           
                       Prior Art                                                                                 
                             Lutzow                                                                              
                13. Lutzow describes a three-layer laminated sheet designed to absorb                            
                liquids, especially hydrocarbon liquids (Lutzow at 3:39–42), which Lutzow                        
                refers to as an "NMN laminate" (id. at 5:37).                                                    
                14. Lutzow's NMN laminate is depicted in Figure 1, shown below:                                  









                15. According to Lutzow, the NMN laminate comprises a layer M of                                 
                meltblown fibers sandwiched between two layers N of "needle punched                              
                fibers" (sometimes called "needle felt"; id. at 4:20–21). (Id. at 3:39-42.)                      
                16. Lutzow describes the needle felt as generally comprising a                                   
                thermoplastic resin (Lutzow at 4:7), preferably a composite of about                             
                30% nylon and 70% polyester (id. at 18–20).                                                      
                17. According to Lutzow, the diameter of the needle punched fibers is                            
                ordinarily larger than the diameter of the meltblown fibers, and preferably                      
                ranges from about 1 to 25 microns.  (Lutzow at 4:13–17.)                                         
                18. Lutzow does not disclose the thickness or density of the needle felt                         
                layer.                                                                                           


                                                       6                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013