Ex Parte Tilton - Page 9

                Appeal  2007-1168                                                                                
                Application 10/211,407                                                                           
                and 0.028 inches, and a fiber diameter of between 1 and 5 microns.  (Sorrick                     
                at 4:17-20.)                                                                                     
                32. The metric conversions of 0.016 and 0.028 inches are 0.04                                    
                and 0.07 cm, respectively.                                                                       
                33. According to Sorrick, the meltblown material must have a minimum                             
                thickness to prevent destruction or damage to the layer during handling prior                    
                to lamination and during the lamination process.  (Sorrick at 2:3–8.)                            
                34. Sorrick teaches further that "a standard layer of melt-blown material                        
                requires at least 0.6 ounces per square yard for any significant stability of the                
                layer."  (Sorrick at 4:51-54.)                                                                   
                35. According to Sorrick, the SMS substrate layer is a composite material                        
                formed from groups of meltblown fibers interspersed between two groups of                        
                spun bonded fibers.  (Sorrick at 4:21–24.)                                                       
                36. According to Sorrick, the three layers of the filter are "joined together                    
                by needling to form an integrated layer of filter material."  (Sorrick                           
                at 2:47-49.)                                                                                     
                37. Sorrick teaches that the needling creates holes [22] through the filter.                     
                (Sorrick at 5:5–10.)                                                                             
                38. According to Sorrick, the holes increase the life of the filter because                      
                small particles take longer to clog them; but the filter is less efficient.                      
                (Sorrick at 5:10-13.)                                                                            
                39. Sorrick teaches that, due to differences in tension between the layers,                      
                the holes will not remain precisely aligned, so meltblown fibers in the SMS                      



                                                       9                                                         

Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013