Ex Parte Bullied et al - Page 9

               Appeal 2007-1488                                                                       
               Application 10/809,072                                                                 
          1               to grow from the starter cavity to the article mold cavity.”                
          2               (Monte ‘469, 2:57-60.)                                                      
          3                                                                                           
          4         Rejection III: Giamei in View of Monte ‘468, Monte ‘469, or Burd                  
          5         17. Giamei’s Figure 7 is reproduced below:                                        













          6                                                                                           
          7         18. Giamei’s Figure 7 is said to depict a ceramic shell mold,                     
          8               wherein relevant reference numerals 34a, 36a, 44a, and 60                   
          9               represent a mold, a first seed, a starter section, and a helical            
         10               selector, respectively.  (Giamei, 5:27-44, 6:9-14.)                         
         11         19. The Examiner found that Giamei describes every limitation of                  
         12               appealed claim 1 “except [Giamei does not disclose] the [use of             
         13               a] grain selector support.”                                                 
         14         20. Applicants do not contest the Examiner’s finding in this regard.              
         15         21. Monte ‘468 and Monte ‘469 both teach the use of a support                     
         16               element for the single crystal selector to support a bend section           


                                                  9                                                   

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013