Ex parte HUCKSTEPP - Page 14




          Appeal No. 94-4061                                                          
          Application 07/659,683                                                      

          one place to the right so that one bit (most significant bit) is            
          shifted off and recirculated and also applied to NOR gate 16                
          (Col. 8, lines 13-15).  NOR gate 16 is also coupled to BIT 1                
          (whose bit pattern has also been shifted to the right) (Col. 8,             
          lines 16-19).  If the two inputs to NOR gate 16 are not the same,           
          NOR gate 16 is enabled (Col. 8, lines 18-20).  The NOR gate 16              
          together with the clocking signal enables AND gate 17 and the               
          processor 10 is reset (Col. 8, lines 19-21).  As long as the                
          processor 10 is operating in a predetermined sequence which                 
          corresponds to the bit pattern stored in shift register 15 and              
          the counter has not counted up, the processor 10 will not be                
          reset.                                                                      
                    Recognizing that Owens does not disclose a "watchdog              
          instruction decoder means connected to an output of said                    
          microprocessor means" as recited in claim 9, the examiner states:           
                    whether the decoder lies inside or                                
                    outside the microprocessor is not                                 
                    critical to the invention as long as the                          
                    means properly function as a detector of                          
                    a watchdog instruction and any means                              
                    including a software CALL ROUTINE                                 
                    execution means inside a microprocessor,                          
                    that detects the watchdog instruction                             
                    and generates activation signals, would                           
                    be equivalent [Examiner's Answer, page                            
                    9, emphasis added].                                               



                                         -14-                                         





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007