Ex parte SWOBODA et al. - Page 29




          Appeal No. 94-3053                                                          
          Application 07/832,661                                                      



                    It would have been obvious to a person                            
                    having ordinary skill in the art to provide                       
                    Poret’s on-chip counters in Hester’s chip                         
                    because they support the clearly desirable                        
                    aspects of increased flexibility in                               
                    controlling debugging operations.                                 
          Answer at 8.  In view of the above discussion with regard to                
          claim 28, we will not sustain this rejection.                               


                    Claim 61                                                          
                    Claim 61 stands rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 in                 
          view of Hester.  Appellants concede that all of the                         
          limitations recited in that claim are met by Hester except:                 
                    issuing a signal from the on-chip condition                       
                    sensor to the electronic processor upon                           
                    detection of the predetermined condition.                         
          Brief at 4-5.                                                               
                    However, Hester meets the above language by teaching              
          that the support processor "include[s] the ability to examine               
          and                                                                         
          alter registers in the system microprocessor" (col. 2, lines                
          59-61) and "control[s] and examine[s] the contents of all                   


                                         29                                           





Page:  Previous  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007