Ex parte SWOBODA et al. - Page 23




          Appeal No. 94-3053                                                          
          Application 07/832,661                                                      



                    LSSD second latches serving as "condition                         
                    sensors", is addressable by a on-chip                             
                    addressing "logic network" 42-48 that                             
                    provides a "multiplexer having inputs                             
                    connected to said sensor circuits" for                            
                    "determining selections of sensor                                 
                    circuits".  LSSD latches 42-44 receive                            
                    "control bits".  It would have been obvious                       
                    to a person having ordinary skill in the                          
                    art to provide a scan string selection                            
                    logic network in accordance with the claims                       
                    on the chip disclosed by Hester, because                          
                    d’Angeac evidences the necessity of such                          
                    logic,                                                            
          answer at 6, and                                                            
                    [a]s the examiner’s answer indicates that                         
                    d’Angeac provides scan loop string                                
                    selection by a logic network 42-48 and the                        
                    examiner’s answer also indicates that                             
                    Hester provides a counter in the form of a                        
                    scannable control register IAR that can                           
                    have its’ data scanned                                            
                    out and in, no further response is deemed                         
                    necessary,                                                        
          supplemental answer at 2.                                                   
                    However, a review of the references relied upon                   
          fails to reveal why a person of ordinary skill in the                       
          electronic processor art would have any reason to modify                    
          Hester’s circuitry to include "a multiplexer having inputs                  
          connected to said sensor circuits and an output connected to                
                                         23                                           





Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007