Ex parte HERBERT - Page 7



         Appeal No. 95-4815                                                        
         Application No. 08/065,387                                                

         data described by Maruko in the display system of Diepstraten             
         and that “[t]he use of 80 clock cycles…would have been an                 
         obvious expedient due to the eighty resultant pixels provided             
         by the 8x10 array” [answer-page 4].                                       
              The examiner’s rationale, in our view as well as in                  
         appellant’s, is unreasonable.  There is a clear implication in            
         the examiner’s rationale that Maruko teaches the writing of               
         one pixel per clock cycle, yet the examiner points to nothing             
         in Maruko, or anywhere else, to support such a position.  We              
         agree with appellant that the “mere fact that the art teaches             
         an 8x10 array does not in any way teach or suggestion [sic,               
         suggest] how such array could be updated within eighty clock              
         cycles, as claimed” [brief-page 11, emphasis in original].                
              We will sustain the rejection of claim 8 under 35 U.S.C.             
         ' 103.                                                                    
              This claim requires the copying of consecutive data words            
         to a range of consecutive addresses and means for receiving               
         the words intended for the range and causing the video                    
         controller to actuate “a column of pixels…”                               
              As broadly recited, Diepstraten’s graphics processor                 
         copies a field of consecutive data words to some range of                 
         consecutive addresses and those data words are then used to               


                                         7                                         



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007