RAPOPORT V. DEMENT et al. - Page 9




          Interference 102,760                                                        
          Memorandum In Support Thereof (Paper No. 119) because                       
          Rapoport’s reply                                                            
          to the Dement et al. Opposition to Rapoport’s Request For                   
          Reconsideration is not authorized by 37 CFR 1.658(b)(Paper                  
          No. 122, p. 2, second para.).                                               
               September 23, 1999 -- Final hearing ensues on Rapoport’s               
          Motion For Judgment Under 37 CFR §1.633(a) or 37 CFR §1.635                 
          (Paper No. 52), the sole issue being the patentability under                
          35 U.S.C. § 102(f) of Claims 1-13 of Dement et al. Application              
          07/695,325, all of which correspond to Count 1 of this                      
          interference.                                                               
          2.   Prior Decisions of the Board                                           
               A.   Conception of Invention of the Count                              
                    (1) “Rapoport has established conception of the                   
          invention of the count by May 13, 1988" (Decision, Paper No.                
          112, page 7, first full para.).                                             
                    (2) “Dement et al. have sustained their burden to                 
          establish conception by the end of summer of 1986, a date                   
          prior to the May 13, 1988 conception of Rapoport, thereby                   
          defeating the Rapoport case for derivation” (Decision, Paper                
          No. 112, p. 9, last para.).                                                 
               B.   Patentability                                                     

                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007