Ex parte PLANKENHORN et al. - Page 8




               Appeal No. 1997-2016                                                                          Page 8                 
               Application No. 08/196,126                                                                                           


               construed as the same as or very close to "vertical face.").  We reach this conclusion based                         
               upon our review of appellants’ specification, which indicates, at page 3, that a semiconductor                       
               substrate "is covered on both sides by glass substrates for obtaining a functional sensor" and,                      
               at page 4, that "a problem occurs, if one or several of the substrates which have to be aligned                      
               with high precision to one another is or are not transparent"  and of the accompanying2                                                     

               drawings, which illustrate round substrates having the same diameter (Figures 1 and 3).                              
                       Hentz is specifically directed to an apparatus and method for aligning and adhering a                        
               plurality of extremely small semiconductor devices (10) to a significantly larger substrate (18)                     
               and thus lacks the limitation in claim 9 that the substrates aligned and deposited one upon                          
               another have "approximately same surface area."  With respect to claim 10, even if the base                          
               (30) and collars (60) are considered an alignment means as claimed for aligning substrates (18),                     
               Hentz still lacks a means for transporting the aligned substrates (18) to a second working area                      
               and for depositing the aligned substrates one upon another, as also required in claim 10.  In                        
               fact, Hentz discloses no structure for transporting an aligned substrate (18) from its position on                   
               the base (30).  While Hentz does disclose means for moving the tubes (26) vertically to thereby                      
               transport the small devices (10) toward or away from the substrate (18), these devices                               



                       2One of ordinary skill in the art would understand from these two statements that the transparent substrates 
               (2, 4) cover the non-transparent substrate but do not extend to any significant degree beyond the periphery thereof; 
               otherwise, alignment marks disposed on the outer transparent substrates beyond the periphery of the non-transparent  
               substrate could be used in conjunction with alignment marks within the periphery of the non-transparent substrate to 
               align all three substrates.                                                                                          







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007