Ex parte PANNELL - Page 10


              Appeal No. 2001-0096                                                                                          
              Application 09/301,891                                                                                        


                     We find claims 5 and 6 of Pannell to be particularly illustrative and reproduce                        
              them below.                                                                                                   
                             5. A bonded composite structure having a pin-reinforced thermoplastic                          
                                weld, comprising:                                                                           
                                a) at least two fiber-reinforced composite elements arranged to define                      
                                    a bond line along an interface between the elements;                                    
                                b) a composite strip of cured resin having X -Y fiber reinforcement and                     
                                    Z-pin reinforcement, the strip being positioned at the bond line; and                   
                                c) a thermoplastic weld between each element and the strip along the                        
                                    interface, the welds including Z-pin reinforcement resulting from                       
                                    penetration of the Z pins in the strip into each weld.                                  
                             6. A bonded composite structure, comprising:                                                   
                                a) at least two fiber-reinforced composite elements arranged to define                      
                                    a bond line along an interface between the elements;                                    
                                b) a composite strip of cured resin having X -Y fiber reinforcement and                     
                                    Z-pin reinforcement, the strip being positioned along the bond line;                    
                                    and                                                                                     
                                c) bonds between the elements and the strip along the interface, the                        
                                    bonds including Z-pin reinforcement resulting from penetration of                       
                                    the Z-pins in the strip into each bond,                                                 
                                wherein the strip includes a metal susceptor susceptible to heating by                      
                                magnetic induction.                                                                         
                     Our review of Pannell’s claims above indicate that they include claims in the form                     
              of a bonded composite structure (see colum n 20, line 44 - column 22, line 5), and are                        
              not merely product-by-process claims as implied by the Appellant’s briefs (Main Brief,                        
              page 4, lines 13-14 and Reply Brief, page 4, line 12).                                                        





                                                            10                                                              



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007