Ex Parte JIA et al - Page 8


         Appeal No. 2002-0142                                                       
         Application No. 09/248,957                                 Page 8          

         further discloses (col. 2, lines 30-39) that to achieve the                
         object of the invention, there is provided a J-K flip-flop                 
         circuit having first and second flip-flop circuits constituted by          
         connecting inputs and outputs of two CMOS inverters to each                
         other, first NAND type connection means in which one end of three          
         MOS transistors, which respectively receive a first clock, a J             
         signal, and a signal from one node of the second flip-flop at              
         their gates, and have current paths connected in series with each          
         other.  Sato further discloses (col. 2, lines 36-39) that one end          
         of the 3 MOS transistors:                                                  
              is connected to one node of the first flip flop                       
              circuit; second NAND type connection means in which one               
              end of three MOS transistors, which respectively                      
              receive the first clock, a K signal, and a signal from                
              the other node of the second flip-flop circuit at their               
              gates, and have current paths connected in series with                
              each other, is connected to the other node of the first               
              flip-flop circuit.                                                    
         The portions of Sato relied upon by the examiner to support the            
         examiner's assertion of asynchronous operation of the first                
         stage, as well as asynchronous set and reset functions are as              
         follows (col. 7, lines 18-25 and lines 45-52):                             
              According to the arrangement shown in FIG. 5, when                    
              the set signal S goes to “H”, the N-MOSFETs 35 and 36                 
              are turned on, and the N-MOSFETs 37 and 38 are turned                 
              off.  Therefore, since the node 3 goes to “L”, the P-                 
              MOSFET 13 is turned on, and the node 4 goes to “H”.  On               
              the other hand, since the node 5 (BQ) goes to “L”, the                
              P-MOSFET 17 is turned on, and the node 6 (Q) goes to                  
              “H”.  In this manner, a set state is established.                     





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007