Phillip M. Welch and Dorothy Ellen Welch - Page 22

                                        - 22 -                                         
             in this case.  Another assumption is that any client who                  
             moves out of Oklahoma County will seek another accountant.                
             That assumption ignores the fact that the Oklahoma City                   
             metropolitan area spans several counties and that a number                
             of other counties are in relatively close proximity to                    
             Oklahoma County.  Contrary to Dr. Alexander's assumption,                 
             it is not apparent that a client who moves to a nearby                    
             county or even to another State will necessarily change                   
             accountants.                                                              
                  Retirement:  Dr. Alexander also considered the effect                
             of retirement on the useful life of the subject client                    
             list.  He analyzed data provided by petitioner showing the                
             fees paid by, and the age of, each client.  He noted "a                   
             dramatic drop-off in fee income per client beginning at age               
             70."  Dr. Alexander concluded that this decrease is due to                
             "the client's having moved into the retirement phase * * *                
             and thereby requiring less fee-based accounting services."                
             His report states as follows:  "Based on our calculations,                
             we estimate * * * a loss of approximately 7.5 percent in                  
             fee income per year due to retirement."  Dr. Alexander did                
             not include his calculations in his report.                               
                  We agree with Dr. Alexander that his chart of the                    
             average fee versus age distribution of clients on the                     
             subject list suggests that the fees paid by clients who                   
             are older than 70 years of age are substantially less than                




Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011