Norwest Corporation and Subsidiaries - Page 28

                                       - 116 -                                        

          also found that no significant degree of technical risk was present         
          in any of the various activities.                                           
               Mr. Teixeira reported that the Success system offered no new           
          or unique features to the banking industry, and that although               
          Success was an improvement from its predecessor, it did not provide         
          industry-leading capabilities.  Mr. Teixeira noted that although            
          some functions, such as the use of e-mail and the ENFORM program to         
          generate reports, improved efficiency, NTS did not discover any new         
          or unique ways to exploit those functions.  He concluded that               
          although no commercially available software could provide exactly           
          the functionality needed by Norwest, there was no doubt about the           
          ability to develop viable equipment leasing software in Norwest's           
          environment.                                                                
               We agree with respondent that the development of the Success           
          system does not constitute qualified research.  All three experts           
          noted the lack of documentary evidence for the Success project, and         
          we note that the record is specifically lacking with respect to the         
          technical risks involved.  It appears that the only project                 
          activity which may have involved technical risk was with respect to         
          the ability to develop Success on the TPF platform.  However, Dr.           
          McDermott was vague about the nature of the technical risk in this          
          regard, and Mr. Teixeira reported that this was a small part of the         
          overall project.  We also note the testimony of Dan Franker,                
          manager of the Success project, who indicated that he never                 
          encountered insurmountable issues with the project and that he              



Page:  Previous  106  107  108  109  110  111  112  113  114  115  116  117  118  119  120  121  122  123  124  125  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011