City of Santa Rosa, California - Page 16

                                        - 16 -                                         
          water to Company, and the wastewater is merely a byproduct of the            
          sewage system.                                                               
               2.   Sewage Ratepayers                                                  
               We first decide whether the sewage ratepayers use the                   
          pipeline as members of the general public, since this                        
          determination is relevant in deciding whether the private                    
          business tests are met.  Under section 141(b)(6)(A), use as a                
          member of the general public is not considered a private business            
          use.  Use of financed property by nongovernmental persons in                 
          their trades or businesses is treated as general public use only             
          if the property is intended to be available, and in fact is                  
          reasonably available, for use on the same basis by natural                   
          persons not engaged in a trade or business.  Sec. 1.141-3(c)(1),             
          Income Tax Regs.                                                             
               Petitioner argues that the use by the sewage ratepayers                 
          involves general public use, that their use is excepted from the             
          definition of private business use, and that such use is not                 
          taken into account for purposes of section 141(b)(1).  Respondent            
          made no determination as to whether the use by the sewage                    
          ratepayers represents general public use.  Further, on brief,                
          respondent states that he has never considered whether the use by            
          the sewage ratepayers involves general public use, because                   
          whether those ratepayers are using the pipeline as members of the            








Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011