City of Santa Rosa, California - Page 15

                                        - 15 -                                         
          determined to be a “use” of the pipeline:  (1) The use is                    
          incidental to petitioner’s governmental use and is not a special             
          legal entitlement or special economic benefit, see sec. 1.141-               
          3(b)(7)(i) and (ii), Income Tax Regs., that results in private               
          business use; or (2) Company’s arrangement should be analyzed                
          under the output facility regulations as an output contract.                 
               With respect to the application of the output facility                  
          regulations, petitioner argues that the financed pipeline is an              
          output facility.  Petitioner contends that the pipeline is a                 
          water facility since it distributes wastewater to Company and the            
          irrigators.  Accordingly, petitioner argues that Company’s                   
          arrangement with petitioner should be analyzed under the output              
          facility regulations.  Petitioner contends that the arrangement              
          with Company will not have the effect of transferring the                    
          substantial burdens of paying debt service on the proposed bonds             
          since Company pays nothing for the wastewater.                               
               Respondent determined that the bond-financed pipeline is “an            
          integral part of the City’s sewage system” and is not a water                
          facility and that the term “output facility” does not include                
          “facilities for the disposal of treated wastewater.”  He agrees              
          with petitioner’s primary contention (in the context of the                  
          private business use test) that the pipeline carries out the                 
          sewage function of petitioner’s sewage system, it provides for               
          the final disposal of wastewater, it was not built to provide                






Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011