City of Santa Rosa, California - Page 26

                                        - 26 -                                         
          users of the pipeline for sewage disposal appear to use that                 
          facility on a generally equivalent basis.                                    
               Respondent seems to suggest that we focus on Company’s                  
          particular use, i.e., its use of the wastewater from the                     
          pipeline, and whether members of the general public use the                  
          wastewater on the same basis as Company.  We do not believe that             
          is the appropriate inquiry under section 1.141-3(b)(7)(ii),                  
          Income Tax Regs.  This special rule focuses on whether the                   
          financed pipeline is available for use by the general public.  We            
          conclude that it is since the sewage ratepayers’ sewage disposal             
          use is as members of the general public.  Their use is                       
          unobstructed by any incidental use and rights that Company may               
          have to the wastewater following its disposal through the                    
          pipeline.  Accordingly, section 1.141-3(b)(7)(ii), Income Tax                
          Regs., does not apply, and the special economic benefit that                 
          Company receives from the pipeline is not sufficient alone to                
          give rise to a private business use.                                         
               Even if we were to assume that petitioner’s arrangement with            
          Company is a private business use of the pipeline, respondent’s              
          determination raises significant questions as to whether such use            
          exceeds 10 percent of the bond proceeds.  Respondent determined:             
                    In this case, one requirement imposed by Company                   
               is that approximately C gallons of wastewater be                        
               delivered each day to the geyser field during the term                  
               of the Contract.  This represents a reservation of                      
               about 27% of the capacity of the Multi-Use Pipeline and                 
               nearly 100% of the Geyser Field Pipeline. This special                  





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011