THOMPSON et al. V. THOMPSON - Page 7




                 Interference No. 103,878                                                                                                               



                 party’s testimony period, “cite specific portions [of the                                                                              
                 junior party’s declarations] and/or provide copies of such                                                                             
                 portions.”                                                                                                                             
                                   The junior party has failed to cite a specific rule                                                                  
                 for this proposition, although he refers in passing to 37 CFR                                                                          
                 §§ 1.672(b); 1.682; and 1.688(d).  We have looked in vain for                                                                          
                 such a provision in the rules.  We find no requirement that                                                                            
                 an opposing party submit to the party presenting evidence a                                                                            
                 description of what portion of the testimony of the party                                                                              
                 presenting evidence will be used in rebutting that evidence.                                                                           
                 We note that the junior party has cited no case dealing with                                                                           
                 this matter.  We know of none.  We acknowledge that 37 CFR §                                                                           
                 1.671(e) requires a party to serve and give notice as to what                                                                          
                 evidence it is relying on.  However, the duty therein does not                                                                         
                 run to an opponent of the party that is serving and giving                                                                             
                 notice.                                                                                                                                
                                   We further note that it is the junior party’s own                                                                    
                 evidence that is sought to be suppressed.   We are in                     6                                                            

                          6We note the following sentence from junior party’s                                                                           
                 motion to suppress.  “Moreover, the failure to cite specific                                                                           
                 portions and/or provide copies of such portions improperly                                                                             
                                                                                                            (continued...)                              
                                                                           7                                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007