Barton et al or Fischhoff et al v. Adang et al. - Page 108




          Interference 103,781                                                        
          (AR 0114, l. 21-22).  He stated (AR 0114, l. 23, - AR 0115,                 
          l. 2):                                                                      
                    A.  Well, abandoned is a bit untrue in this case.                 
               A bit overstated.  Okay?  We had . . . some experiments                
               on identifying destabilizing regions that we were                      
               following up on up until the termination of Agrigenetics               
               . . . in August, 1988.                                                 
               The question we must ask is whether the wealth of                      
          experimentation which Drs. Adang and Murray and their associates            
          performed to identify the destabilizing regions of the Bt gene in           
          plants transformed thereby are representative of the exercise               
          reasonable diligence toward reduction to practice of the                    
          invention of Claim 1 of Adang’s involved patent corresponding to            
          Count 2.  Pertinent to the issue is the following question with             
          Dr. Adang’s reply (AR 0116, l. 16-21):                                      
                    Q.  Did you believe that identifying the enhanced                 
               destabilizing region would be necessary in order for                   
               your invention involving increasing the number of                      
               plant-preferred codons in the native Bt gene to work?                  
                    A.  No.                                                           
               The work Dr. Murray performed in 1986 and thereafter to                
          create codon usage tables for plants is not the same work Dr.               
          Adang performed no later than 1986 relating to codon usage in Bt            
          genes.  Consider the following testimony by Dr. Adang (AR 0119,             
          l. 17, - AR 0120, l. 3):                                                    
                    Q.  . . . Now, do you remember who it was that did the            
               work relating to codon usage in Bt genes?                              

                                        -108-                                         





Page:  Previous  101  102  103  104  105  106  107  108  109  110  111  112  113  114  115  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007