Barton et al or Fischhoff et al v. Adang et al. - Page 110




          Interference 103,781                                                        

                    Q.  As a result of looking at codon usage tables                  
               published for plant genes and comparing those to your codon            
               usage table for the Bt gene, did you draw any conclusion?              
                    A.  We concluded that the Bt genes had different codon            
               usage and different preferred codons than plant genes.                 
                                      . . . . .                                       
                    Q.  So the “we” is you and Elizabeth Murray?                      
                    A.  Yes, that’s correct.                                          
                    Q.  . . . Did you identify specific codons in the                 
               native Bt gene that occurred more frequently than in plants?           
                    A.  In looking at the native Bt genes, a feature that             
               was striking to me was the number of codons ending in As               
               or Ts at the wobble base position.                                     
                    Q.  Why is that striking?                                         
                    A.  Well, it was striking because that’s in opposition            
               to or quite contrast to plant gene.  You know, plant genes             
               are rich in Gs and Cs at the third nucleotide position.                
                    Q.  Do you recall drawing any other conclusions as a              
               result of the comparison you made between your codon usage             
               table for the native Bt gene and the published data                    
               involving codon usage in plants?                                       
                    A.  Well, I recall that we took the step of saying                
               Bt genes should be made to look more plant-like by building            
               to include codons preferred and match the usage of plant               
               codons.                                                                
          Thereafter, when asked about the first time after November of               
          1985 that Liz Murray, or anyone else, communicated to him a                 
          comparison of codon frequencies for Bt genes and codon                      
          frequencies for plants (AR 0128, l. 10-13), Dr. Adang testified             
          (AR 0128, l. 14-18):                                                        

                                        -110-                                         





Page:  Previous  103  104  105  106  107  108  109  110  111  112  113  114  115  116  117  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007