Ex Parte D - Page 9

                Appeal 2007-3412                                                                               
                Application 10/832,450                                                                         
                molecular weights to synthesize a PVB (Toyama at 2:42–60) and then                             
                blending 30 to 70 parts per hundred of a plasticizer (id. at 7:42–53).                         
                41. Esters, including dihexyl adipate, are named as preferred plasticizers;                    
                certain diesters of triethylene glycol are particularly preferred.  (Toyama                    
                at 7:11–41.)                                                                                   
                42. Toyama discloses that dynamic viscoelasticity measurements yield the                       
                ratio of the storage elastic modulus to the loss elastic modulus ("the loss                    
                tangent," also referred to as "tan δ").  (Toyama at 9:45–49.)                                  
                43. According to Toyama, when the tan δ measurement is carried out as a                        
                function of temperature, tan δ assumes a maximum value at a temperature                        
                that "corresponds to the glass transition temperature (Tg), that is to say the                 
                softening point, of the material."  (Toyama at 9:49–55.)                                       
                44. Toyama teaches that when Tg is near room temperature, sound                                
                insulation performance is "remarkably good," but that the PVB film                             
                becomes too soft to handle easily, and the impact resistance of the laminated                  
                glass "tends to be insufficient."  (Toyama at 9:56–63.)                                        
                45. Toyama teaches that glass laminates meet its objectives when the                           
                temperature corresponding to the maximum of tan δ is not over 30°C.                            
                (Toyama at 9:40–44.)                                                                           
                46. In Example 1, Toyama describes a laminate using a PVB plasticized                          
                with 60 phr of a diester, but no properties of the laminate are disclosed.                     
                (Example 1 at 15:51 to 16:9.)                                                                  
                47. Toyama exemplifies a number of glass laminates having PVB layers                           
                plasticized with 39 or 40 phr ester, having tan δ maximum temperatures                         


                                                      9                                                        

Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013