Garber Industries Holding Co., Inc. - Page 13

                                       - 13 -                                         
                    b.  Family Attribution and Aggregation                            
               Intrafamily sales were excluded from the operation of former           
          section 382(a) by means of stock attribution (as opposed to                 
          shareholder aggregation) rules.  Specifically, purchases of stock           
          from persons whose stock ownership would be attributed to the               
          purchaser under the family attribution rules of section 318 were            
          ignored for purposes of determining whether an ownership change             
          by “purchase” had occurred.  See former sec. 382(a)(3) and (4).             
          Although family members were potentially subject to aggregation             
          for purposes of determining the 10 largest shareholders at                  
          yearend, that rule applied only if loss corporation stock owned             
          by one was attributed to the other under the family attribution             
          rules of section 318.11  Former sec. 382(a)(2) and (3).  For that           
          reason, the aggregation rule of former section 382(a)(2), unlike            
          the aggregation rule of section 382(l)(3)(A)(i), necessarily                
          applied as of the date on which stock ownership was measured (in            
          the case of former section 382(a)(2), at yearend).  Accordingly,            
          no inference can be drawn from former section 382(a)(2) as to               
          whether, as respondent maintains, the identification of the                 
          individuals whose family members are aggregated under section               


               11  Persons aggregated under former sec. 382(a)(2) were then           
          disaggregated for purposes of measuring changes in stock                    
          ownership.  See former sec. 1.382(a)-1(d)(3)(i), Income Tax Regs.           
          (as revised in 1968).  Thus, the actual number of persons whose             
          stock ownership was subject to scrutiny at yearend could be                 
          greater than 10.                                                            





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011