Garber Industries Holding Co., Inc. - Page 22

                                        - 22 -                                        
          report to “grandparents” in the context of section                          
          382(l)(3)(A)(i).  Staff of Joint Comm. on Taxation, General                 
          Explanation of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 at 311 (J. Comm. Print            
          1987).                                                                      
               As is the case with the conference committee’s excision of             
          the family status provision of the House bill, see supra part               
          III.E.2.d., the substitution of “grandparents” for                          
          “grandchildren” in the 1986 conference report makes perfect sense           
          if the family aggregation rule applies solely from the                      
          perspective of individuals who are shareholders of the loss                 
          corporation.  Section 318(a)(1) (to which section 382(l)(3)(A)(i)           
          refers) is phrased in terms of the family members (spouse,                  
          children, grandchildren, and parents) from whom shares are                  
          attributed.  The converse of that rule is that shares owned by an           
          individual are attributed to that individual’s spouse, parents,             
          grandparents, and children.  The substitution of “grandparents”             
          for “grandchildren” in the 1986 conference report (reiterated in            
          the 1986 Blue Book) therefore suggests that Congress intended               
          individuals to be aggregated with the same family members to whom           
          their shares would otherwise be attributed under section                    
          318(a)(1), which in turn suggests that Congress intended the                











Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011