THOMPSON et al. V. THOMPSON - Page 20




          Interference No. 103,878                                                    



                    We acknowledge that the junior party has argued that              
          Milling’s testimony is ambiguous, for in some instances her                 
          testimony could possibly be interpreted to refer to both                    
          Henson and Milling working together.  In this regard, we                    
          merely note that ambiguous testimony, whether from a putative               
          inventor or    a putative corroborator, does not militate for               
          establishing a conception by a preponderance of the evidence.               
          Ambiguous testimony from Milling cuts against any legal                     
          conclusion that Henson was an inventor.  Due to this lack of                
          corroboration, it  is our conclusion that the junior party has              
          not established that Henson is a co-inventor.                               
                    With respect to Wilkerson, it is our finding that                 
          Wilkerson was outdoor products manager at Hubbell.  JP41.                   
          When Brammer received the facsimile drawing from Henson, he                 
          referred                                                                    
          it to Wilkerson.  JP41.  Wilkerson stated that his                          
          contributions to the invention were finding a reflector head                
          with the correct parabolic shape, moving the latches to fit                 
          the standard NEMA head, and specifying a diffuse finish to                  
          give a uniform spread  of light.  JP51-52.                                  


                                          20                                          





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007