CHEUNG et al vs. RITZDORF et al - Page 24




                Interference No. 105,113                                                                                                      

                The wafer or workpiece 490 is supported on its bottom side by a hot plate 530 while cooling air                               
                535 moves from left to right across the top surface, as indicated by arrows 535.  Id. at 24, ll.                              
                18-22.  Although not discussed in the specification or given reference numerals, the dashed lines                             
                at the left and right sides of the figure appear to represent left and right side walls.  Adjacent to                         
                and outside the left wall is a rectangle which we assume, based on the position and direction of                              
                arrows 535, represents the source of the cooling air.  The right side wall includes an opening                                
                through which the cooling air presumably exits after passing over the wafer.  While the figure                                
                does not show front and back side walls, it is reasonable to assume they were omitted from the                                
                drawing because their presence is not required to show the path of the cooling air across the                                 
                wafer.  Thus, we conclude that this figure is sufficient to show that the inventors envisioned an                             
                annealing apparatus having surrounding sides, thereby satisfying the annealing "chamber"                                      
                terminology of independent claims 68, 70, and 73.  Furthermore, when this annealing apparatus                                 
                is employed in the system depicted in Figure 16,  the "system" limitation and the remaining                                   
                elements of these claims are also satisfied for the reasons given above in the discussion of the                              
                annealing "oven" embodiment.                                                                                                  
                         For the same reasons, these claims read on the system depicted in Figure 17, reproduced                              
                above, when it employs the annealing apparatus of Figure 11 as the heating unit 635 in annealing                              
                station 630.  However, we note in passing that although heating unit 635 is described as being                                
                "separate" and although annealing station 630, which contains heating unit 635 and a dedicated                                
                robotic mechanism 640, is connected to the other system component through "an intermediate                                    
                staging door/area 645" (id. at 28, ll. 10-14), we do not agree with Ritzdorf that these                                       
                                                                   - 24 -                                                                     





Page:  Previous  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007