Ex parte KIKUDA - Page 11




          Appeal No. 96-0511                                                            
          Application 08/158,837                                                        


          original input data signal D " (col. 7, lines 11-17).  The                    
                                       IN                                               
          meaning of this passage in Tanigawa is unclear, because                       
          Tanigawa's drawings and detailed description of the testing                   
          procedure nowhere show or describe a comparison of D  with                    
                                                                out                     
          D .  Instead, as noted above, Tanigawa detects defective                      
           IN                                                                           
          memory cells by examining the voltages at terminals TO1-TO4                   
          (Fig.5), all of which are derived from the fetched data                       
          appearing on DB1-DB4, to determine whether they are all the                   
          same; if they are not, there is a defect in one of the four                   
          memory cells being tested.  For this reason, Tanigawa does not                
          inherently employ "temporarily storing" means for holding the                 
          test data until it can be compared to the fetched data, as                    
          required by claim 23.  As will appear, neither this deficiency                
          in Tanigawa nor the other deficiencies discussed below are                    
          remedied by Childers or Furutani.                                             
               The examiner concedes that Tanigawa fails to disclose                    
          claim 23's "means for simultaneously transferring said                        
          external data in each single row of said preliminary memory                   
          cells . . . to a corresponding single row of said plurality of                
          memory cells . . . via said bit lines connecting said                         
          plurality of memory cells and preliminary memory cells."  For                 
                                        - 11 -                                          





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007